19.11.2026
Two corpses and a minghun wedding
No annual conference, no branches, no democracy. Now we are told Left Unity has affiliated. Carla Roberts reminds us that traditionally, in China, a ghost marriage sees reburial in a common grave
Last week’s news that Left Unity has been “approved for affiliation” to Your Party has been met with a fair amount of surprise - and understandable derision.
For a start, who knew that Left Unity was still going? Formed in 2013 after an appeal by Ken Loach - long since departed from LU - and effectively run by CND’s Kate Hudson and her partner, Andrew Burgin, it had at its high point about 2,000 members - quite a respectable number, considering that both the Socialist Workers Party and the Socialist Party stayed well clear. Of course, the agreed platform was hardly radical. It aimed for a party that “stands for equality and justice”, not socialism or communism. It harked back to the “spirit of ’45”, when “we saw the post-war generation transforming the lives of ordinary people by bringing improved health, housing, education and social security to the people of Britain”.
Nevertheless, it was relatively democratic and open. There were no bans and proscriptions of organised Marxists and, for a while, CPGB comrades organised as the ‘Communist Platform’, where we fought for LU to become a Marxist party. We campaigned against the identity politics of some in the leadership and successfully fought against an attempt to enforce a draconian ‘safe space policy’ (with the result that the proposed text was ‘deferred’ at the 2013 conference and there is now no mention of it).1 Yassamine Mather was elected onto the Left Unity national council in March 2014 - a year later we had a four-strong fraction.
However, Left Unity’s fortunes changed dramatically in September 2015 when a certain Jeremy Corbyn was elected leader of the Labour Party. We argued that LU should seek to affiliate to the Labour Party and urged LU members to join as individuals and help transform Labour into a united front of a special, permanent, kind. However, the Hudson/Burgin line of ‘carry on as before’ won out and sealed LU’s fate.
According to a motion at its last national conference (which took place on Zoom in April 2026, attendance figures unknown), “there has been a gradual decline in the membership to its current level of less than 250”. We would be surprised if there are more than 25 members. To our knowledge, there are no branches - at its peak, there were about 70 of them. There is the occasional, entirely inconsequential article posted on its website, but this is not a living organisation.
Some have speculated that it is Left Unity’s status as an ‘Associated Member’ of the European Left (full members include Die Linke in Germany, Syriza in Greece and Rifondazione Comunista in Italy - ie, parties of ‘recomposition’) that makes it “attractive” to Your Party - after all, going to international talking shops is the kind of thing that Corbyn absolutely loves. However, surely Corbyn is not short of invitations to such jamborees and Your Party could simply attempt to join as a proper member, rather than sneak in via LU’s semi-attached “associated” status (which is shared by such important groups as Democratic Left Scotland and Socialists for the Independence of Scotland).2
No, it is much more likely that this weirdly timed affiliation is simply down to the slow, bureaucratic pace of their matchmakers. The motion to seek affiliation was agreed at LU’s conference in April, so it was probably drafted a couple of months before that - ie, when it looked like Your Party might yet have a bit more life remaining to it.
Left Unity’s statement too seems to have been written many months ago. It laughably states:
… after decades without a mass political party representing working class interests, Britain’s left is entering a new chapter. The emergence of Your Party offers fresh opportunities to build a progressive political alternative to neoliberalism. With Left Unity now officially affiliated to Your Party, the potential for greater cooperation, solidarity and a stronger, united socialist movement is growing.
How deluded can you be?
Sheffield
Take Your Party’s ‘introductory Sheffield branch meeting’, which took place on November 10 on Zoom. We were told there are 616 members remaining across the six and a half constituencies in Sheffield (presumably non-paying former ‘members’ are counted too). Thirty-one bothered to come to the meeting - a fair way off the 20% quorum imposed by the Corbyn clique at the launch conference. It is also well below the 200 or so members who came to the first few meetings of the vibrant Sheffield proto-branch.
No wonder Karie Murphy has not allowed the ‘official’ launch of the branch until now - it was one of the most lively and outspoken areas, launching many a petition against the undemocratic shenanigans of the bureaucracy. That spirit has not quite gone away. For example, there was opposition to the fact that two blokes from “south Scotland” were running the meeting. They clearly had not a clue about what is going on in South Yorkshire. There were plenty of bad-tempered questions that they could not (or would not) answer - for example, why branches would only receive a measly “one-off payment of £500”. As one participant quickly calculated, the 616 members in Sheffield would have paid over £33,000 in membership fees in the last 12 months.
And why won’t there be a conference this year? “That is not for us to answer”, the meeting was told more than once by chair Ross McCann and Zoom host ‘Ryan’. Those two eventually got so exasperated that they kicked out a member who had asked a few inconvenient questions in the chat - for being “disruptive”. When others in the meeting complained, pointing out that the comrade was “critical rather than disruptive”, the chair told us that “he had sent a lot of abusive private messages to me” - a claim that, as far as we can establish, was untrue. When that was pointed out, the meeting was abruptly closed down.
Not surprisingly, a couple of days after the meeting, an email informed us that the “nomination phase of the Sheffield YP branch has been extended”. Only one officer nomination had been received - for workplace liaison. None for chair, treasurer, secretary or organiser. It is pretty much the same everywhere.
So what about the missing annual conference? While members in Sheffield received no reply, comrades in Plymouth were told that “conference doesn’t need to be annual, and the membership merely needs to be consulted annually”.3 The Corbyn clique is shamelessly violating its own constitution. Written and forced through at Liverpool, it is perfectly clear: “3.a.i. The party shall have an annual national conference, which, in addition to hearing reports on the party’s activities, shall consider issues of party policy, party structures and organisation.”4
Transparency
There is also the question of who drew up or agreed to the “affiliation agreement” with Left Unity. Certainly not Your Party’s elected leadership, which last met in July.5 That meeting was so bad-tempered and contentious that chair Jenn Forbes has not called a meeting since - no doubt at the behest of Jeremy Corbyn’s right-hand woman, Karie Murphy.
After all, even a few of those central executive committee (CEC) members elected on Corbyn’s ‘For the Many’ slate have become so fed up with the failure of Your Party to harness its initial support that they can no longer be relied upon to do as they are told. It was Jo Rust, elected on Corbyn’s slate in the East of England, who in early July moved the no-confidence vote against chair Jenn Forbes and membership secretary Dawn Aspinall.
The motion, in response to the haphazard suspension of three CEC members for allegedly attending a meeting of the Socialist Federation (now deceased), gained the votes of a majority of CEC members. But because that CEC meeting had not been called by Forbes, the Corbyn clique simply ignored the outcome. The ‘opposition’ has since entirely collapsed - no surprise really, as there was no agreed alternative plan and no political coherence.
A number of members have since resigned from the CEC altogether, including three supporters of the opposition Grassroots Left (Sophie Wilson, Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi and Solma Ahmed). Numerous former Corbyn supporters too have resigned their officer posts, including spokesperson Noor Begum, political officer Louise Regan and treasurer Fadel Takrouri (although they remain on the CEC). So perhaps it was the four remaining members of the YP officers’ group that took the decision? Or perhaps Murphy simply informed them after the fact.
There is no transparency, no report about how the “affiliation agreement” was reached or what it entails - or if there have been any other such affiliation applications. Affiliation is, after all, the only way to avoid ‘expulsion’ for being a member of another organisation. Although the Liverpool conference voted in favour of ‘dual membership’, the Corbyn clique has maliciously interpreted this the other way around - and has since expelled a couple of dozen members of various left groups. This witch-hunt has temporarily stalled, probably because there is nobody left to actually implement it.
And there certainly is no transparency around the ‘legal issues’ involving YP - or who exactly got the Metropolitan Police involved. In October the Met launched a “criminal investigation relating to the alleged unauthorised access of a political party’s database”.6 As comrades know, this is about Zarah Sultana rather ill-advisedly launching a membership portal in September 2025 in order to force Corbyn’s hand. He had been dithering for many months about giving the green light. More than 20,000 signed up. And, although the Corbyn clique subsequently (and very reluctantly) accepted that it would have to set up a membership scheme, it refused to acknowledge the ‘Zarah portal’ and launched a separate one - no doubt in the knowledge that this would be a ‘gotcha’ moment to neutralise the impatient Sultana, who had already become a thorn in the Dear Leader’s side.
Legal threats
For a considerable time, the Corbyn clique refused to accept the membership fees that Sultana tried to send them, and it was months before the two databases were eventually merged. In the meantime, Corbyn’s Peace and Justice Project referred Your Party to the Information Commissioner’s Office, which came to the conclusion that Your Party “should consider referring the incident to the police in order to determine whether ‘serious criminal activity’ occurred”. Should - not must. In other words, YP could have left it at that. But no. The Corbyn clique decided to go fully nuclear.7
Anybody vaguely familiar with YP knows, of course, who the “26-year-old man” is who was arrested in October. It is, however, less clear who the “39-year-old woman” is who was reportedly interviewed under caution. Zarah Sultana is 33 years old and we read that “no MP” was questioned. Time may tell.
In any case, it is clear that the Corbyn clique has acted in a disgusting and unprincipled way. Socialists should not get the police or bourgeois courts involved in what is, at the heart of it, a political matter. (We take a different view when it comes to serious criminal questions, like rape or worse - this is not something left organisations can sort out themselves under present-day conditions, as the SWP’s comrade Delta affair proved.)
Your Party might linger on as a ghostly online-only presence, presided over by a self-serving Corbyn clique, spending accumulated membership fees on staffers and pointless foreign trips. But Left Unity’s affiliation will not bring it back to life.
Traditionally, in China, two dead people can marry. It is called minghun. A bride price is paid, there are burnt offerings and a wedding reception is held where the couple is represented by wooden spirit tablets. The defining, final step involves reburial of the two corpses in a common grave. YP and Left Unity deserve each other.
-
weeklyworker.co.uk/worker/1211/end-the-farce.↩︎
-
www.european-left.org/about-us/our-parties.↩︎
-
www.weeklyworker.co.uk/worker/1609/letters/.↩︎
-
docs.google.com/document/d/1Zj8kh2jhFvMCGVJUzgtB4RH38JNKWcBp0B1VT7pUIEA/edit?tab=t.0.↩︎
-
www.yourparty.uk/cec-docs.↩︎
-
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/16/met-police-investigating-row-over-founding-of-your-party.↩︎
-
www.jewishnews.co.uk/man-arrested-as-police-probe-your-party-database-dispute.↩︎
