Letters
Friendly polemics?
On the question of the Netherlands left, Filip Spijkerman attacks the points of unity of the recently founded Faction for a Revolutionary Strategy (FRS) in his letter (October 8). He posits that our first point is that “no meaningful engagement with the broader Dutch left is possible, and that focus should be only on building the RSP [Revolutionary Socialist Party]”. However, this does not accurately reflect our position. So allow us to quote in full:
“We fight for a mass socialist party. On the one hand, this mass party must be firmly rooted in the labour movement and able to intervene in it. On the other hand, it must forge unity amongst revolutionary groups. However, there are currently only a very small number of relevant groups on the Dutch socialist scene. Of these groups, the RSP is the largest organisation. The second-largest organisation, the CPN [the KKE-aligned Communistische Partij van Nederland, formerly prefixed with Nieuwe], is opposed to a merger.
“The most important way to build the socialist mass party is therefore not, at present, to engage with existing leftwing groups, but to build the RSP as a party. In doing so, the qualitative development of our members must be our top priority. In doing so, engaging with other socialist groups and the movement is a way of distinguishing the RSP from others and demonstrating that we are non-sectarian and democratically organised, with the right to form factions, and that we advocate principled, leftwing, revolutionary socialist politics. In this way, we can strengthen the RSP’s position in the current political landscape, and that is the most powerful weapon for forging unity within the Marxist movement.”
Everyone is free to disagree with these tactical considerations, but to simply say that our faction opposes engagement with other Marxist groups and proposes only the building of the RSP on its own is just quite a weak lie. Comrades who read the point of unity in question will notice the following. Firstly, the necessity of unity among the various revolutionary groups is addressed explicitly. Secondly, the faction posits that the CPN is opposed to a merger of any kind; this is a fact. To drive the point home, it is quite clear to any observer that it’s CPN policy to refuse to acknowledge all other communist organisations in public.
The reason the CPN is singled out here is practical: it is the only other sect which clears a 50-member threshold, and one of probably only three Dutch grouplets which boast over 20 active members. Thirdly, it very clearly advocates engagement with both socialist groups and the movement as a whole.
This point of unity thus does not mean we disavow engagement with the sectarian leftist groups. Rather, this engagement should have as its target audience not the leadership or committed members, but the broader movement or uncommitted members of the target group. Polemics usually only create animosity among the committed members of the group polemised against, but - when done in a friendly, but firm, way - can have a positive effect on non-committed members and people in the broader movement. In addition, these people can be reached through engagement with them directly, and do not only respond to polemics.
These two points combined can lead to growth among the non-sectarian elements, in order to make the leadership of the sectarian groups irrelevant in the future. Then they hopefully will find reason to engage with the non-sectarian, democratic party, and the slogan, ‘One class, one party’, can be achieved. We hope to elaborate further on these tactical considerations in the future.
All comrades interested in reading and discussing our faction’s points of unity, Mr Spijkerman included, are invited to shoot us an email at revolutionairestrategie@gmail.com.
FRS
Netherlands
Jobs for youth
I see that Alan Milburn has come up with a plan to get rid of those ‘not in education, employment or training’ (Neets). It seems to be mostly about cutting benefits to pay for training - along with helping businesses to take on young people by cutting regulation and national insurance. I haven’t noticed any extra money for local, or indeed national, government.
I have been puzzled in looking for the jobs that are to be found for newly trained youngsters. What is needed? Airline pilots, train drivers? Cleaners, security folk? Police, prison officers? Hairdressers, manicurists? Who knows? When I was a lad many years ago, there were jobs in mining, shipbuilding, housebuilding, car manufacturing, textiles - you know the sort of thing. But it’s China, Thailand, Bangladesh and other places that do lots of those things nowadays.
I think Milburn has to give us some more information on the government’s options here. Perhaps Andy Burnham will tell us before Christmas?
Jim Nelson
email
Attack on youth
Seriously ill and disabled 16- to 24-year-olds are to be cured by being paid a new “youth allowance” at the Universal Credit standard rate, instead of PIP (personal independence payment) and the health element of UC. The latter has already been halved for new claimants despite being available only to people who had been found medically unfit for work. If you doubt the extreme difficulty of that, then try it. There are 690,000 job vacancies in the United Kingdom, and there are 1.7 million people seeking them. This would put that second figure above 2.5 million.
None of this has anything to do with either making people better or finding them work. This is about saving money by killing them. Yes, really.
We are talking about one of Tony Blair’s closest allies here. Whoever is to sort out the problem of young people who were “not in education, employment or training” (Neet), it is no job for a perpetual student. Alan Milburn started a PhD in 1979, but he has never finished it. Instead, with Blair and with Paul Corrigan, he brought NHS privatisation from the outer fringes of the thinktank circuit to the very heart of government. We already have a good idea how he intends to repeat the trick. Third- and fourth-generation middle class teachers in primary schools will identify potential future Neets. In secondary schools they will deliver to them a curriculum designed by and for the local vape shops, phone shops, nail bars, tattoo parlours, carwashes, mini-marts, adult gaming centres, Turkish barbers, American candy shops, and lap dancing clubs - there being nothing else (not even Poundland). And without trade unions no-one will be able to come up through those to enter the political process.
David Lindsay
Lanchester
In the shredder
In the 1980s, the British government began introducing hefty fees for foreign students at our universities. I joined the overseas student movement which fought these measures. We attempted to win over home students and, whilst some joined, many said, ‘They won’t do it to us!’ Thirty-plus years later, English students pay almost £10,000 in fees for a single year at a university.
I remembered those events when reading Milburn’s ghastly plans to impoverish young English people below the age of 25. Young people in England are suffering huge anxiety, as the failed neoliberal system cannot deliver a reasonable lifestyle for many of us - old and young. Many youngsters suffer depression, unable to see a light at the end of the capitalist tunnel.
The Labour Mensheviks are targeting young people, who are often less versed in how successive governments of all hues have failed us. Instead of resigning en masse, the Labour wonks blame us. This is simply a measure to provide super-cheap labour to prop up failed businesses. Once they are finished robbing the young, the centrists will look for other victims.
After two years of huge handouts under Sunak, thousands of crap businesses were kept afloat. Their owners had that time to either close their business and move into another sector or join the wage slaves. Instead we have them bleating on TV like beggars, whining about their difficulties. They are nothing like the mythical risk-takers that the neoliberal apologists wax lyrical about.
Should these measures pass, Milburn 2.0 will target other parts of our population. Already where I live, I observe people well past pension age working in shops, driving buses, etc. The ruling class want us to work till we drop, whilst they swan about playing croquet and eating canapés on a workday - and then go skiing in Chamonix in winter and spend the summer arsing about on their yachts.
The end of the triple lock on pensions is outrageous. Currently the annual payment for the British state pension is £12,000. That means automatic poverty for those of us without savings or private pensions. Already 1-2 million pensioners languish on such sums.
No, these cruel measures will not pass. We stopped the serial harmer, Starmer. Now let’s block Burnham. Put Milburn’s plan in the shredder!
K Sean
Kent
AXA targeted
The support of transnational insurance company AXA for fossil fuels has been condemned at several climate protests, as COP31 was taking place in Turkey.
In various demonstrations, participants carried signs with messages such as “AXA: full gas towards the end of the world!” and “AXA is the real climate rioter!” The climate movement, Action Non-Violente Cop21 (ANV Cop21), which initiated these messages, is calling on AXA to stop supporting fossil fuel projects - particularly those involving liquefied natural gas (LNG) - which are exacerbating the ongoing climate crisis.
For several months, the climate movement, ANV Cop21, and other organisations, such as Reclaim Finance, have criticised the insurance company for its support of fossil fuels, particularly in the LNG sector.
Juliette Caroulle, spokesperson for ANV Cop21, stated: “While countries around the world are once again gathering to address the impacts of climate disruption, which we must absolutely limit, AXA is doing exactly the opposite by supporting fossil fuel projects that exacerbate the problem. Instead of protecting people from the impacts of climate change, AXA is actually contributing to intensifying disasters and increasing the damage and the number of victims: this is the behaviour of a ‘fireman-arsonist’ that we cannot tolerate!”
These new climate protests were part of the European Day of Action for Climate organised by Climate Action Network Europe, which brings together 200 organisations in 40 countries, and coincided with the International Day of the Rights of the Child.
Action Network
email
Off UK soil!
We will be holding our regular monthly vigil outside the gate of RAF Lakenheath this Saturday (November 21) from noon to 2pm. This coincides with the Day of Action Against Militarisation and Conscription which has events running across the country.
We have been holding vigils outside the base since April 2024, as well as several peace camps and other events. We have voiced our concerns with a ‘Letter to the Base Commanders’, which was delivered to the base. There has been no response so far. These concerns include the siting of nuclear weapons at the base, the involvement in the attacks on Iran and support for Israel, including the transfer of F-35I jets to Israel in January this year.
Zareen Taj from the Lakenheath Alliance for Peace and Cambridge Stop the War said: “Alleged threats to Mildenhall and Lakenheath recently have distressed locals, who said they really felt the fear that those in war zones feel when an imminent strike is expected.” She continued: “Our UK government has made us complicit in US-Israeli aggression through the use of our UK bases. Along with the ongoing genocide of Gaza, we are now embroiled in the illegal war on Iran. US bases off UK soil now!”
Lakenheath Alliance for Peace
email
Significant book
The looming deadline for my article in last week’s Weekly Worker whilst travelling by train meant I couldn’t give any feedback on ‘What made us “hunter-gatherers of words”?’ - a one-day interdisciplinary workshop at the Historical Materialism conference, bringing together researchers from archaeology, anthropology, cognitive and language sciences, neuroscience and evolutionary biology to explore the origins of human language and the social and cultural conditions that made it possible.
Just like the book, The revolutionary origins of language, also being launched there that day, the workshop was of great and unique significance, bringing together a range of speakers and topics over three sessions, all for free. Some of it demanded a rather more advanced level of understanding than I have, including the first session by Chris Sinha from the University of East Anglia, who was speaking on ‘Late stages in the evolution of language and the creation of the social imaginary’, so I was actually delighted when Chris Knight, whom I was sitting beside, leaned into me and said, “I disagree with everything he has said”!
But, with that other Chris going on to chair later sessions and the differences between them being discussed openly in a comradely way, it showed further similarities to the CPGB approach of embracing open, ideological struggle as a vital component of the ongoing search for credence of scientific theories.
Among the many sessions from which I could gain further understanding of the human revolution that happened with the origins of language was the one entitled ‘Gender dynamics and morality’ by Morna Finnegan and Ingrid Lewis - a collaborative talk, using theory, ethnography and film on Bayaka gender dynamics: “We propose that women’s procreative solidarity is central to the maintenance of egalitarian process and social morality. Drawing on Mbendjele women’s own assertions of inviolability, we argue that morality is fundamentally a corporeal element: it has to be communally bodied in order to remain live.”
Morna suggested that all attending the workshop actually get in physical touch with those either side of us, as that is the way the Mbendjele community live - she has spent time with them and witnessed this first-hand. This level of contact is an expression of such egalitarian, hunter-gatherer, collective power. She also said that the new book gives voice to that collective body. One of the most remarkable and vivid expressions that Morna used previously to describe the pendulum of power dynamics between male and female members of the tribe was “communism in motion”.
Another striking description given by Ingrid Lewis, who has spent much time in similar fieldwork with her husband and co-author of the book, Jerome, is that “we took the intelligence out of the water” and I took that to tie in with the work of Elaine Morgan - of course, I should have asked about that in the discussion, but missed that (until now) in the midst of it all.
Something I certainly did grasp was Ingrid telling us that we have characteristics going so far and deeply back to our origins of ‘connection’, and babies are so clearly born with that. And they both emphasised that organising around the most vulnerable in society - babies, children and the elderly - is the essence of egalitarianism. Again, communism in action.
I think the most tantalising for me of all the talks came from Francesco d’Errico, who presented ‘Symbolic cognition and culturalisation of the body’. This leading archaeologist looked at the evolution of symbolic cognition in human lineages, scaffolded through culturalisation of the body.
This was a fascinating look at the origins of fashion and what it has meant for humanity from our very origins. This dovetailed well with the contribution from RAG veterans Ian Watts and Camilla Power, on ‘Red ochre: portal to ritualised bodies and another world’.
I’ve still done little justice to the sheer amount of origins knowledge poured forth from the workshop and comrades should keep an eye on the RAG Vimeo channel, where all of the workshop contents will be posted as soon as possible. Meanwhile, if you haven’t already, read Jack Conrad’s review of Chris Knight’s book (‘Dancing the world’ Weekly Worker November 12) and do yourself a favour - buy it and read it for the most mind-blowing discoveries of the original human revolution that it’s our task to emulate.
Tam Dean Burn
Glasgow
